The New Economy

In 1999, I called one of my professors from graduate school who taught monetary theory.  Let’s call him Joe.

Here’s a short summary of the conversation:

Me:  Professor Joe,  can you believe how big this stock market bubble has grown?

Prof Joe:  It’s a new economy, [Gregor].

I put down the phone in astonishment.  Professor Joe drank the kool-aide.

In hindsight,  indeed he was right, but not for the reasons he had concluded.

The economy did change in the 1990’s as is illustrated in the charts below.   Not, however,  for the reason Wall Street was touting to justify extreme asset valuations.

The New (Wealth Driven Asset) Economy 

Household net worth, or asset prices, became more volatile and a much bigger driver of economic growth as illustrated in the charts below.  The second chart normalizes the data by gross domestic product.

The average change in household net worth on a quarterly basis relative to GDP from 1952 to 1994 was 6.17 percent with a standard deviation of 4.68 percent.  Since 1995, the average change has been 5.89 percent, but the standard deviation has more than doubled to 10.21 percent.   The similar mean of the two periods most likely reflects the mean reverting nature of asset returns.

Why The Change?

We posted a couple reasons we believe were the cause for this financial and economic structural shift in the mid-90’s:

1) Moral Hazard

First,  moral hazard was internalized by traders and investors.   Though the “Greenspan put” was born almost a decade earlier after the 1987 stock market crash,  the 1994-1995 monetary tightening culminated in the collapse of the Mexican peso and set off the Tequila Crisis in emerging markets.  The U.S. government had to step in and bailout Mexico with $50 billion-plus in loans…

2) Money Velocity

Second,  the rise of the internet and technological changes fundamentally changed the U.S. economy and its payments system.   We do not have time to research the specifics, but we suspect it is reflected in the secular decline in money velocity which peaked in the 1990’s and has fallen ever since with the exception of a small bump just before the credit/bubble popped…

3) Asset Markets Became The Economy

The labor shock caused by the entry of China and Eastern Europe into the global economy contributed to a significant hollowing out the U.S. middle class as policymakers failed to compensate the losers of free trade.  They were effectively swept under the rug as globalization took off, corporate profits soared, and consumer prices were held in check with cheap imports.  This effect culminated in the 2016 political Black Swan.

Fundamental Shift In Aggregate Demand

It is our contention the decline in the purchasing power of a relatively large swath of  Americans, with a relatively high propensity to consume, were crippled and when coupled with the rapid rise in income and wealth inequality aggregate demand has become insufficient to drive economic growth at an adequate pace…  – Global Macro Monitor,  Feb 5, 2018

If you haven’t seen the post,  Start Of A Mean “Mean Reversion” In Stock Values?, run don’t walk to read it. 

.

Net Worth_Mar5

.

Net Worth_GDP_Mar5

Upshot?

Our hypothesis that the economy is becoming more influenced by asset prices and debt, and to a lesser extent by income (which is endogenous) due to a secular stagnation in real wages, is a work in progress.

Moreover, the whole inflation/deflation debate has morphed into a dialectic, which is path dependent on asset prices.   Stocks values move up to a critical level (which holders likely believe to be permanent) that stirs the animal spirits and kicks economic growth into gear.  Inflation eventually becomes an issue moving interest rates higher.  The asset bubble pops, stock values go down,  confidence declines, aggregate demand softens and deflation now becomes the headline issue.   Wash, rinse, repeat.

In addition, each asset cycle results in greater divergent of valuations from the economy (see charts below) as the wealth disparity increases.   The marginal propensity to consume is much higher for middle and working class consumers.   As wealth becomes more concentrated at the higher end, aggregate demand weakens on a relative basis and more theoretical wealth is needed to generate the same demand.

“The wealthy buy Apple stock with their gains, whereas the middle class buy apples.”

We have run some preliminary statistical analysis and regressions and thus far the data do support our priors.  Back to you when we complete the analysis.

.

MeanR_1

.

MeanR_2

This entry was posted in Economics, Uncategorized and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

74 Responses to The New Economy

  1. So doesn’t the divergence between income and wealth seem to happen immediately following the tax reform packages of the mid-1990s? The tax reform that dramatically improved taxes on capital gains and made housing subject to multiple capital gains exclusions? It lifted real estate prices, but was that really good for the economy? Seems to me the issues we have are not really related to individual actors, they are policy choices.

    • Brian says:

      Rigging the economy to favor the wealthy has been an ongoing theme covering everything from tax policy to banking regulation to healthcare insurance to foreign wars. It is totally about the policy of a run-amok big government unconstrained by sound money.

  2. Pingback: Exposing The New (Asset-Wealth-Driven) Economy - Sell The News

  3. Pingback: Exposing The New (Asset-Wealth-Driven) Economy - LILES FILES

  4. Pingback: Exposing The New (Asset-Wealth-Driven) Economy – iftttwall

  5. Pingback: Exposing The New (Asset-Wealth-Driven) Economy - Novus Vero

  6. Pingback: Exposing The New (Asset-Wealth-Driven) Economy | Real Patriot News

  7. Pingback: Exposing The New (Asset-Wealth-Driven) Economy | Investing Daily News

  8. Pingback: Exposing The New (Asset-Wealth-Driven) Economy | Newzsentinel

  9. Pingback: Exposing The New (Asset-Wealth-Driven) Economy | StockTalk Journal

  10. Pingback: Exposing The New (Asset-Wealth-Driven) Economy – TradingCheatSheet

  11. Pingback: Exposing The New (Asset-Wealth-Driven) Economy – Wall Street Karma

  12. Pingback: Exposing The New (Asset-Wealth-Driven) Economy – The Daily Bulletin

  13. Pingback: Breaking News - DollarCollapse.com

  14. Pingback: Exposing The New (Asset-Wealth-Driven) Economy – TCNN: The Constitutional News Network

  15. Pingback: Weekend Reading: Social Benefits Nation | RIA

  16. Pingback: Weekend Reading: Social Benefits Nation - Investing Matters

  17. Pingback: The Looming Donnybrook Between Cyclical & Structural | peoples trust toronto

  18. Pingback: The Looming Donnybrook Between Cyclical & Structural | Investing Daily News

  19. Pingback: The Looming Donnybrook Between Cyclical & Structural – TradingCheatSheet

  20. Pingback: The Looming Donnybrook Between Cyclical & Structural | Real Patriot News

  21. Pingback: The Looming Donnybrook Between Cyclical & Structural | CENSORED.TODAY

  22. Pingback: The Looming Donnybrook Between Cyclical & Structural | StockTalk Journal

  23. Pingback: The Looming Donnybrook Between Cyclical & Structural – Wall Street Karma

  24. Pingback: The Looming Donnybrook Between Cyclical & Structural – ProTradingResearch

  25. Pingback: The Looming Donnybrook Between Cyclical & Structural – TCNN: The Constitutional News Network

  26. Pingback: President Reagan On The ’87 Stock Market Crash | peoples trust toronto

  27. Pingback: President Reagan On The ’87 Stock Market Crash | Investing Daily News

  28. Pingback: President Reagan On The '87 Stock Market Crash | StockTalk Journal

  29. Pingback: President Reagan On The ’87 Stock Market Crash – Conspiracy News

  30. Pingback: President Reagan On The '87 Stock Market Crash – Wall Street Karma

  31. Pingback: President Reagan On The ’87 Stock Market Crash | Real Patriot News

  32. Pingback: President Reagan On The '87 Stock Market Crash – ProTradingResearch

  33. Pingback: People’s QE Is Coming And The Result Will Be A Disaster | peoples trust toronto

  34. Pingback: People’s QE Is Coming And The Result Will Be A Disaster – students loan

  35. Pingback: People’s QE Is Coming And The Result Will Be A Disaster | StockTalk Journal

  36. Pingback: People’s QE Is Coming And The Result Will Be A Disaster | Real Patriot News

  37. Pingback: The Gathering Storm In The Treasury Market – Viralmount

  38. Pingback: The Gathering Storm In The Treasury Market – The Deplorable Patriots

  39. Pingback: The Gathering Storm In The Treasury Market – students loan

  40. Pingback: The Gathering Storm In The Treasury Market | peoples trust toronto

  41. Pingback: The Gathering Storm In The Treasury Market – iftttwall

  42. Pingback: The Gathering Storm In The Treasury Market | Zero Hedge

  43. Pingback: The Gathering Storm In The Treasury Market | Site Title

  44. Pingback: The Gathering Storm In The Treasury Market | GEOECONOMIST

  45. Pingback: The Gathering Storm In The Treasury Market - Novus Vero

  46. Pingback: The Gathering Storm In The Treasury Market | COLBY NEWS

  47. Pingback: The Gathering Storm In The Treasury Market | StockTalk Journal

  48. Pingback: The Gathering Storm In The Treasury Market - open mind news

  49. Pingback: The Gathering Storm In The Treasury Market | SPLIT INSTITUTE

  50. Pingback: The Gathering Storm In The Treasury Market – The Trading Letter

  51. Pingback: The Gathering Storm In The Treasury Market – Forex news – Binary options

  52. Pingback: The Gathering Storm In The Treasury Market - forexdemoaccountfree.com

  53. Pingback: The Gathering Storm In The Treasury Market – top10brokersbinaryoptions.com

  54. Pingback: The Gathering Storm In The Treasury Market – secretsforex.com

  55. Pingback: The Gathering Storm In The Treasury Market - megaprojectfx-forex.com

  56. Pingback: The Gathering Storm In The Treasury Market – Forex news forex trade

  57. Pingback: The Gathering Storm In The Treasury Market - aroundworld24.com

  58. Pingback: The Gathering Storm In The Treasury Market – forex-4you.com, الفوركس بالنسبة لك

  59. Pingback: The Gathering Storm In The Treasury Market - noticiasp

  60. Pingback: The Gathering Storm In The Treasury Market – The Conservative Insider

  61. Pingback: The Gathering Storm In The Treasury Market - forex analytics Forex Factory provides information to professional forex traders; lightning-fast forex news; bottomless forex forum; famously-reliable forex calendar; aggregate ...

  62. Pingback: La Tempête Sur Le Marché Du Trésor – forex-enligne-fr.com

  63. Pingback: The Gathering Storm In The Treasury Market – forexreadymax.info

  64. Pingback: The Gathering Storm In The Treasury Market – Binarybrokersblog.com – binary options trade forex

  65. Pingback: The Gathering Storm In The Treasury Market – fastforexprofit.com, الفوركس بالنسبة لك

  66. Pingback: The Gathering Storm In The Treasury Market – 4-forex.info

  67. Pingback: The Gathering Storm In The Treasury Market – stocksoptionsandforex.com

  68. Pingback: The Gathering Storm In The Treasury Market – myforexx.info

  69. Pingback: The Gathering Storm In The Treasury Market – forex analytics forexpic.com

  70. Pingback: The Gathering Storm In The Treasury Market – comparforex.com

  71. Pingback: The Gathering Storm In The Treasury Market - entertainment-ask.com

  72. Pingback: The Gathering Storm In The Treasury Market – customchakra.com

  73. Pingback: The Gathering Storm In The Treasury Market – mudahnyaforex.com

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s